Insight
When might a shareholder transaction need an independent valuation?
A shareholder transaction changes more than the names on a register. It may affect control, access to future returns and the relationship between owners. An independent valuation can provide an evidence-based reference point when people have different expectations about price.
It is not automatically required for every transaction. Whether a valuation is needed, and what it must address, depends on the governing documents, transaction structure and applicable requirements. A lawyer or tax adviser should confirm those requirements for the particular circumstances.
When an owner enters or leaves
A founder’s retirement, a management investment or the departure of an existing owner can create a need to assess a shareholding. An independent assessment may help the parties separate the value question from other negotiations, such as payment terms, future employment or restraints.
Define exactly what is being transferred. A sale of existing shares, a new share issue and a company buy-back have different mechanics. A valuation does not replace the legal and tax work needed to structure and complete the transaction.
When an agreement specifies a valuation process
Start with the constitution and shareholders agreement. ASIC’s guidance on shares and shareholders identifies these documents as sources of shareholder rights and responsibilities.
Ask your lawyer whether the documents specify a valuation date, basis, formula, appointment procedure or treatment of particular rights. Resolve unclear instructions before commissioning a report. A well-prepared valuation can still be unsuitable if it answers a different question from the agreement.
When parties are connected
Transfers within a family or between related entities may have objectives beyond negotiating the highest sale price. Documenting the commercial reasoning and obtaining relevant advice can help distinguish the agreed consideration from a valuation conclusion.
Where a tax provision requires market value, the applicable rule needs to be identified rather than assumed. The ATO’s market valuation guide explains its expectations for evidence and process. An independent valuation does not guarantee acceptance by the ATO or determine the tax treatment of the transaction.
When the shares carry different rights
Share classes may differ in voting, dividends, conversion or participation in an exit. Transfer restrictions and other contractual provisions can also be relevant. The interest being valued should therefore be described precisely, supported by the governing documents.
For example, a proposed minority investment should not be evaluated solely by multiplying a whole-company figure by the percentage being acquired. The valuer needs to consider the relevant rights, agreed basis and transaction context. Any adjustment requires support; it should not be treated as an automatic rule.
When disagreement has become part of the process
Owners may disagree about sustainable profits, growth expectations or the effect of an owner’s departure. A clear scope and documented information process can make those differences easier to identify and discuss.
If the matter is disputed, take legal advice on the appointment and reporting requirements. Agree who instructs the valuer, how information is provided and who may rely on the report. Independence should be assessed at engagement, including relevant relationships or conflicts.
Agree the question before the number
Prepare a short brief covering the proposed transaction, relevant entities, shareholding, valuation date, intended users and deadline. Provide ownership documents, financial information and any relevant previous offers or transactions. Explain which terms are agreed and which remain open.
If the company will buy back shares, seek advice on the separate corporate process. ASIC explains that buy-back rules vary by type; a valuation alone does not complete those requirements.
Explore estate and shareholder valuation matters, tax and succession valuations or request a consultation to discuss the valuation scope alongside your existing advisers.
Further reading
- ASIC: company shares and shareholders.
- ASIC: company share buy-backs.
- ATO: market valuation for tax purposes.
Related reading
- Enterprise value vs equity value: a worked example
- Business valuation vs business appraisal: what’s the difference?
General information only. The appropriate valuation approach and requirements depend on the circumstances, agreed scope and intended use. This article is not a valuation of a particular business or individual legal, tax or financial advice.
Free guide
Start your business valuation with the right questions.
Get our six-page guide to valuation purpose, approaches and preparation, plus four practical follow-up emails. Unsubscribe at any time.
Get the free valuation guide