Insight
How to brief a business valuer for a family-law matter
A useful family-law business valuation starts with a precise question. “What is the business worth?” can mean the operating business, all shares in a company, one person’s shareholding, or an interest connected with several entities. A report answering the wrong question can leave substantial work unresolved even if its calculations are sound.
The brief connects the legal issue with the financial analysis. This guide explains the practical decisions to make with the instructing lawyer before information is gathered and a report commissioned.
Confirm the purpose and proposed appointment
Explain whether the work is intended to inform negotiations, support mediation, review an existing valuation or provide proposed expert evidence. These uses can require different instructions and outputs. An initial discussion with a valuer does not establish a court appointment or determine that a report will be suitable for evidence.
For proceedings in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia, the rules address joint appointment, written instructions and an expert’s overriding duty to assist the court impartially. The instructing lawyer should confirm the appropriate appointment, communication arrangements and applicable requirements before work begins. See Part 7.1 of the Family Law Rules.
Western Australian matters need a separate jurisdiction check. The Family Court of Western Australia has its own rules and procedures; do not assume a federal court briefing process applies unchanged.
Identify exactly what is being valued
Provide the legal entity names and a simple group chart. Distinguish the trading business from any service company, premises-owning entity, investment entity or trust. Include the relevant share classes, percentage interest and governing documents rather than relying on a trading name.
For example, a practice might pay rent to a related property entity and a service fee to another company. The valuer needs to understand both arrangements to assess the subject interest and avoid counting the same income or asset twice. A headline business value cannot simply be copied into every entity’s balance sheet.
Where the subject is a particular shareholding, identify its rights and restrictions. Whether an adjustment for control or transferability is appropriate depends on the interest and instructions; it is not an automatic percentage deduction.
Specify the date and basis of value
The valuation date tells the valuer which financial and commercial circumstances to assess. The report date tells the reader when the work was completed. They may differ. Ask the lawyer to confirm the required date rather than assuming that separation, a financial year end or the hearing date must always apply.
The brief should also state the required basis of value and any legal assumptions. For a historical date, explain which records survive and identify later events separately. The report should make its treatment of later information clear, rather than silently importing subsequent success or failure into an earlier assessment.
Frame answerable financial questions
A concise issues list is usually more useful than a large collection of correspondence without a cover note. Useful questions might include:
- What earnings are sustainable after allowing for the work performed by the owners?
- How should identified non-recurring expenses or related-party charges be analysed?
- What debt, cash and other assets reconcile the operating business value to the specified equity interest?
- How sensitive is the conclusion to a documented alternative assumption?
- Which information gaps materially restrict the analysis?
Avoid instructions to justify a target value. If a factual issue is disputed, describe each position and its evidence. For example, one party may expect an owner to continue working while another assumes replacement management. Ask whether separate scenarios would help, without asking the valuer to resolve witness credibility.
The Court’s experts’ conference guidance explains the role of competing assumptions and distinguishing agreement from disagreement. This makes a disciplined issues list useful well before any conference is arranged.
Provide an organised, traceable information pack
Supply an index identifying the entity, period and source of each document. Financial statements, current accounts, ownership records, material agreements and explanations of unusual transactions give the valuer a starting point. Our family-law valuation document checklist explains how these records fit together.
Mark draft accounts and management estimates clearly. Keep a list of missing documents and nominate who can obtain them. If explanations conflict, retain the alternatives rather than merging them into a single apparently agreed fact. The lawyer should manage disclosure, confidentiality and any restrictions on sharing material.
Address professional-practice issues early
In a dental practice valuation or medical practice valuation, the owner’s clinical work, referral relationships, practitioner arrangements, premises and equipment can be important to the analysis. Identify who generates the revenue, the terms on which they work and what the business would need to pay to replace their functions.
Start with aggregated operational information. Patient records and identifying clinical information should not be included in a general briefing pack. Agree any necessary information request and appropriate handling process first.
Plan beyond the first report
Give the proposed mediation or hearing date and allow time for records, questions and responses. Ask the valuer to distinguish the initial report fee from possible updates, supplementary questions, conferences or attendance. Confirm capacity for the proposed timetable before treating availability as settled.
Use the family lawyer valuation briefing pack to organise your initial instructions. Evident Valuations is based in Sydney and discusses business valuation requirements for disputes and family-law matters across Australia, subject to the scope, suitability and independence checks for each engagement.
Start a valuation enquiry with a high-level outline of the interest, purpose and deadline, or book a free 15-minute consultation. This article is general information; your lawyer should direct the legal and procedural requirements for your matter.
By Evident Valuations. Published 20 September 2026.
Free guide
Start your business valuation with the right questions.
Get our six-page guide to valuation purpose, approaches and preparation, plus four practical follow-up emails. Unsubscribe at any time.
Get the free valuation guide