Family law and commercial disputes
Business valuations for disputes and family law
Business valuation support for family-law property matters, shareholder disagreements, commercial disputes and mediation, with the scope and intended use defined at the outset.
Sydney-based. Supporting clients and advisers across Australia.

When business value is disputed, the explanation behind a figure matters. The subject interest, valuation date, financial evidence and assumptions need to be clear enough for the parties and their advisers to understand where a difference arises.
Evident Valuations is based in Sydney and discusses business valuation requirements for family-law property matters, shareholder disagreements and commercial disputes across Australia. Each engagement begins with the proposed purpose, independence, suitability and available information.
Family-law business valuation requirements
A property matter may involve an operating business, a private shareholding, a professional practice or interests connected with several entities. The scope should identify the actual asset or interest, rather than relying on a trading name or a percentage of an unexplained headline value.
Your legal adviser should confirm the proposed appointment, required date, basis of value and intended use. Under the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia’s expert rules, impartial duties to the court take priority over the interests of the party paying the fee. Any proposed expert engagement needs to address the applicable requirements. See Part 7.1 of the Family Law Rules. Western Australian matters require consideration of their own court rules and procedures.
A discussion about an engagement does not establish a single-expert appointment or guarantee that a report will be admitted or accepted. Legal advisers should settle those procedural questions before substantive work starts.
Shareholder and commercial disputes
Ownership disagreements can involve the operation of a valuation clause, an owner’s exit, competing views of maintainable earnings or the value of a specified interest. Relevant shareholder, partnership and transaction documents help define the question. Your lawyer should provide the interpretation of disputed contractual or legal provisions to be used in the analysis.
For mediation and negotiation, a clear explanation of the drivers of value can help focus discussion. Where assumptions remain contested, an agreed scope may examine alternative scenarios and show which differences materially affect the conclusion. A business valuation and a claim for economic loss are distinct assignments and should be scoped accordingly.
Financial issues that often need attention
- Owner dependence: the work owners perform and the cost of replacing those functions.
- Related-party arrangements: rent, service fees, employment and transactions requiring explanation.
- Business value and equity value: how cash, debt, other assets and intercompany balances are treated.
- Ownership rights: the specific interest and any rights or restrictions relevant to the instructions.
- Historical information: records available at the required date and the treatment of later developments.
- Unresolved assumptions: clearly identifying what is agreed, disputed or unsupported.
For healthcare businesses, explore our dental practice valuation and medical practice valuation pages. Clinical work, practitioner arrangements and the income retained by the business may require separate analysis.
Preparing instructions and records
Start with the parties and entities, purpose, valuation date, deadline and the main issue in dispute. Relevant instructions, orders and agreements should accompany an indexed information pack once the appropriate exchange process is agreed.
Financial statements, current accounts, ownership records, loan schedules and explanations of unusual transactions are common starting points. Existing reports can help identify the issues, but their assumptions and intended use must be understood before relying on their conclusions.
Our family lawyer valuation briefing pack, guide to briefing a business valuer and family-law valuation document checklist help organise an initial discussion.
Scope, reporting and timing
An agreed report can set out the question, evidence, methodology, material assumptions, reasoning and limitations. Multiple entities, incomplete records, historical dates and disputed information affect the work required. Tell us about mediation or hearing dates early so capacity and information dependencies can be considered.
Report updates, supplementary questions, conferences and attendance are separate scope considerations. Their availability and fees should be addressed expressly, rather than assumed to be included in an initial valuation report.
Discuss your matter
Start a valuation enquiry with a high-level description, or book a free 15-minute consultation. Please arrange the appropriate exchange process before sending confidential financial or court records. Accountants and lawyers can also read about working with Evident Valuations.
Read about Calvin’s experience and our valuation approach.